Reference: CCPR/C/104/D/1914, 1915 & 1916/2009

Decision Year: 2012.03.21

Information Source: Human Rights Committee’s Follow-up Report on Views (CCPR/107/3) & Follow-up Report on views (Oct. 2014)

According to the Victim or his/her Counsel:

Committee’s assessment 130th session (CCPR/C/130/3):

• (a) Investigation: E;
• (b) Retrial or release: C;
• (c) Reparation, including appropriate compensation: E;
• (d) Non-repetition: B.

Committee’s decision: Follow-up dialogue ongoing.

Committee's assessment 118th (CCPR/C/118/3):

• (a) Investigation: B2
• (b) Retrial or release; and full reparation: C2
• (c) Publication of the Views: No information (d) Non-repetition: C1

Committee’s decision: Follow-up dialogue ongoing.

Committee’s assessment (from the 113th session):

• (a) Investigation: C1
• (b) Retrial or release, and full reparation: C2
• (c) Publication of the Views: No information
• (d) Non-repetition: C1

Committee’s decision: Follow-up dialogue ongoing.

Committee's decision 115th (CCPR/C/115/3): Follow-up dialogue ongoing.

Committee's assessment 113rd (CCPR/C/113/3):

• (a) Investigation: C1
• (b) Retrial or release, and full reparation: C2
• (c) Publication of the Views: No information
• (d) Non-repetition: C1

Committee’s decision: Follow-up dialogue ongoing.

Committee's assessment 112nd (CCPR/C/112/3):

• (a) Investigation: C1
• (b) Retrial or release; and full reparation: C2
• (c) Publication of the Views: No information

Committee’s decision: Follow-up dialogue ongoing.

Committee's decision at Annual Report A/69/40 (VOL I): Follow-up dialogue ongoing. The Committee’s recommendation has not been implemented.

Related Articles:

• Article 14.3 (b) Article 14.3 (d) Article 14.3 (e) Article 14.3 (g) Article 2 Article 7 Article 9.3

Keywords:

• Arbitrary detention Fair hearing Right to defence Right to legal assistance

Full Case:

• link En

Implementation

Committee’s assessment 130th session (CCPR/C/130/3):

• (a) Investigation: E;
• (b) Retrial or release: C;
• (c) Reparation, including appropriate compensation: E;
• (d) Non-repetition: B.

Committee’s decision: Follow-up dialogue ongoing.

Committee's assessment 118th (CCPR/C/118/3):

• (a) Investigation: B2
• (b) Retrial or release; and full reparation: C2
• (c) Publication of the Views: No information (d) Non-repetition: C1

Committee’s decision: Follow-up dialogue ongoing.

Committee’s assessment (from the 113th session):

• (a) Investigation: C1
• (b) Retrial or release, and full reparation: C2
• (c) Publication of the Views: No information
• (d) Non-repetition: C1

Committee’s decision: Follow-up dialogue ongoing.

Committee's decision 115th (CCPR/C/115/3): Follow-up dialogue ongoing.

Committee's assessment 113rd (CCPR/C/113/3):

• (a) Investigation: C1
• (b) Retrial or release, and full reparation: C2
• (c) Publication of the Views: No information
• (d) Non-repetition: C1

Committee’s decision: Follow-up dialogue ongoing.

Committee's assessment 112nd (CCPR/C/112/3):

• (a) Investigation: C1
• (b) Retrial or release; and full reparation: C2
• (c) Publication of the Views: No information

Committee’s decision: Follow-up dialogue ongoing.

Committee's decision at Annual Report A/69/40 (VOL I): Follow-up dialogue ongoing. The Committee’s recommendation has not been implemented.