Reference: CCPR/C/102/D/1756/2008

Decision Year: 2011.07.19

Information Source: Victim & Follow-up Report on views (Oct. 2014)

According to the Victim or his/her Counsel:

Committee's assessment 127th session (CCPR/C/127/3):

• (a) Investigation and prosecution: C;
• (b) Full reparation, including appropriate compensation: B;
• (c) Non-repetition: No information.

Committee’s decision: Close the follow-up dialogue, with a note of partially satisfactory implementation of the Committee’s Views.

Committee's decision 117th (CCPR/C/117/3): Resume the follow-up dialogue in the case and inform both parties accordingly.

Committee's assessment 112nd (CCPR/C/112/3):

• (a) Remedy: C1
• (b) Publication of the Views: No information
• (c) Non-repetition: B1

Committee’s decision: While taking note with satisfaction of positive general measures aimed at preventing future violations, suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of the Committee’s recommendation.

Committee's provisional assessment at Annual Report A/69/40 (VOL I):

• C2 (Reply received but not relevant to the recommendation)

Committee’s decision: Follow-up dialogue ongoing. The Committee’s recommendation has not been implemented. On 11 March 2014, the Special Rapporteur met with members of the State party’s delegation present for the examination of the State party’s periodic report.

Related Articles:

• Article 2.3 Article 6.1 Article 7

Keywords:

• Right to life Torture / ill-treatment

Case Summary: link Click Here

Full Case:

• link En link Fr link Sp

Implementation

Committee's assessment 127th session (CCPR/C/127/3):

• (a) Investigation and prosecution: C;
• (b) Full reparation, including appropriate compensation: B;
• (c) Non-repetition: No information.

Committee’s decision: Close the follow-up dialogue, with a note of partially satisfactory implementation of the Committee’s Views.

Committee's decision 117th (CCPR/C/117/3): Resume the follow-up dialogue in the case and inform both parties accordingly.

Committee's assessment 112nd (CCPR/C/112/3):

• (a) Remedy: C1
• (b) Publication of the Views: No information
• (c) Non-repetition: B1

Committee’s decision: While taking note with satisfaction of positive general measures aimed at preventing future violations, suspend the follow-up dialogue, with a finding of unsatisfactory implementation of the Committee’s recommendation.

Committee's provisional assessment at Annual Report A/69/40 (VOL I):

• C2 (Reply received but not relevant to the recommendation)

Committee’s decision: Follow-up dialogue ongoing. The Committee’s recommendation has not been implemented. On 11 March 2014, the Special Rapporteur met with members of the State party’s delegation present for the examination of the State party’s periodic report.